Table of contents
Op-ed / Debate

Simplicity Is Essentially a State of Mind

To live more simply means getting off the treadmill of mindless consumerism.
A gray ocean fades into a gray sky, with a few swimmers barely visible in the distance.

Upsplash/Image Catalog

This article contributes to the debate, “Why We Yearn for the Simple Life

Simplicity is an elastic term that can mean just about anything. Consider Andrew Carnegie, the steel magnate and robber baron who by the early 20th century was the richest man in the world. In retirement, Carnegie dedicated himself to philanthropy while living what he described as a simple life—much of which he spent in his Scottish castle surrounded by 32,000 acres. While his castle was a far cry from today’s tiny house movement, Carnegie genuinely thought he was practicing a simple life of salmon fishing, golf, and sailing.

Everything is relative, especially simplicity—there is no guidebook or checklist to follow. Throughout American history, various groups have had quite different views about how and why one should embrace a simpler life. In the late 18th century, America’s founders called for citizens to curb their selfish passions in order to sustain the world’s largest republic. (There was considerable irony in this, as Thomas Jefferson’s simple life, for example, was enabled by a battalion of enslaved workers.) During the 19th century, promoters of a simpler life rhapsodized more about living in harmony with nature than about following religious mandates or the protocols of civic virtue. Quakers and the Amish, among others, profess pietistic simplicity to ensure that their lives revolve around their faith, not their goods. Other advocates of simplicity over the years have displayed a similar range of motives and methods, ironies and hypocrisies.

The elusive ideal of simple living exercises a persistent appeal because people, even in this techno-crazy 21st century, continue to want more from life than going ever faster and buying more things. For all of its virtues, however, simplicity remains a devilishly hard way of life because it flies in the face of modern materialism. Like David battling Goliath, those who seek simplicity war against a dominant consumer culture that barrages us daily with seductive wares and beguiling promises.

Fortunately, simplicity demands neither an end to economic growth nor a vow of personal poverty. A simpler life’s basic requirement is not a rural homestead or a monastic regimen, for simplicity is fundamentally a state of mind rather than a particular standard of living. Money, possessions, and activities in and of themselves do not corrupt simplicity; it is the love of money, the addiction to possessions, and the lure of conformity that corrode our ideals. Consumer goods are like food; everyone needs some, but there’s a subtle tipping point in our devotion beyond which consumerism can degrade our pursuit of happiness.

Committing to simplicity means engaging in a deliberate, daily ordering of priorities so as to distinguish between what is necessary and superfluous, useful and wasteful, beautiful and vulgar. Simplicity-minded consumers interrogate their motives for wanting something new, better, or bigger, and they learn to say no to indulgence—with grace. 

Those who are eager to move out of the fast lane must chart their own path to simplicity because each of us starts from a different place. Those who choose a simpler life—even Carnegie—discover that pressures are reduced, the frenetic pace is slowed, and “higher” priorities are established and sustained. Liberating oneself from the addiction of money-making and the anxieties of status-seeking can promote inner peace and prosperity of spirit. The more we simplify, the more abundant our lives become in those areas that really matter: family, community, personhood, and spirituality.

David E. Shi sacrificed simplicity to serve as president of South Carolina’s Furman University from 1994 to 2010. He is an American intellectual historian who has published two books about simplicity in the American experience: The Simple Life: Plain Living and High Thinking in American Culture and In Search of the Simple Life: American Voices, Past and Present. He received his Ph.D. from the University of Virginia in 1976. Shi is also a co-author (with George Brown Tindall) of the best-selling book America: A Narrative History, now in its 10th edition, and is at work on a cultural history of loneliness.


You may republish this article, either online and/or in print, under the Creative Commons CC BY-ND 4.0 license. We ask that you follow these simple guidelines to comply with the requirements of the license.

In short, you may not make edits beyond minor stylistic changes, and you must credit the author and note that the article was originally published on SAPIENS.

Accompanying photos are not included in any republishing agreement; requests to republish photos must be made directly to the copyright holder.


We’re glad you enjoyed the article! Want to republish it?

This article is currently copyrighted to SAPIENS and the author. But, we love to spread anthropology around the internet and beyond. Please send your republication request via email to editor•

Accompanying photos are not included in any republishing agreement; requests to republish photos must be made directly to the copyright holder.